Design Recognition – 1991 Kaiulani Mahalo Mintliner Award Medal

Just a note about my recent acquisition of the 1991 Kaiulani “Mahalo Mintliner Award” medal. I was rather surprised that many of the RHM collectors stayed away and did not bid on this medal.

First, it was not listed in the RHM publicly available information and may have been the primary reason for the low bidding activity.

Second, “mahalo” is thank you in the Hawaiian language. The medal is thanking someone.

Third, the term “mintliner” makes no sense and may have kept away bidders. However, you can derive a meaning if you think “headliner”. As a “mintliner”, one can see it as getting your mint recognized among all mints or peers in the minting business.
Fourth, the term “award” means the medal is being awarded to someone.

Fifth, the full name of the RHM mint master, Bernard Von NotHaus, is on the medal. The medal is being awarded to him or with his approval to a recipient (most likely employees of RHM). In either case, the mintage would be small and not sold to the general public.

Lastly, I know the reverse design. It was used previously on a larger coin. If collectors recognized it, bidding activity may have been stronger. See the images (note the decorative design in the center top and bottom).

Design Recognition - 1991 Kaiulani Mahalo Mintliner Award Medal

1991 Kaiulani 21mm (size of 1/4 oz gold) Bronze Pattern

1991 Kaiulani 21mm (size of 1/4 oz gold) Bronze Pattern

New acquisition. Undocumented die paring. 1/4 oz gold obverse paired with a new (unrecognized) reverse die. Very crisp strike on a polished bronze planchet.

I believe this is a bronze pattern and was to be struck/may have been struck in gold.

I contacted the seller prior to bidding and he assured me that Telle Presley (co-founder of Royal Hawaiian Mint) confirmed it was struck in bronze. Unfortunately. no mintage numbers. However, this coin completes my 1991 Kaiulani Design metal type collection (bronze, silver, gold, and platinum). There is only 1 documented bronze striking of the 1991 Kaiulani design, but luckily this pattern appeared.

Waterhouse Token on Ebay

It’s my opinion the price is too high…

http://www.ebay.com/itm/1860-Hawaii-Waterhouse-Trade-Plantation-Token-PCGS-Certified-Genuine-Very-Rare-/330953876286?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4d0e63633e

A June 5th Heritage Auction lot 5441 sold for $1880 (final price with buyers premium) for a damaged token also.

http://coins.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=1186&lotNo=5441

I also did bid on the Heritage sale, but price was above my set limit.

Wailuku Plantation Token on Ebay

I did bid on the exact same token as listed in the June 5th Heritage Auction (lot 9607) that is now listed on Ebay.

I lost due to over bidding.

Hammer price was $616.88 (final price with buyers premium).

http://coins.ha.com/c/item.zx?saleNo=1186&lotNo=9607

Marked up by $278.12 (buy it now $895).

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Very-Scarce-HAWAII-1871-Wailuku-12-1-2-Cents-Narrow-Starfish-PCGS-VF-Details-/151077461719?pt=Coins_US_Individual&hash=item232ceb1ed7